SacRT board 2026-11-09 policy approach

I wrote reactions to the policy suggestions that will be presented today at the SacRT board meeting: SacRT board 2026-11-09 4.1 customer service. What I did not write about is how the board should approach this.

These rider-facing policies are too important to leave to staff. Though it has never been verbalized, it seems that staff intent is that staff develop and implement the policies without board approval. The implementation of a zero-tolerance policy for all violations, without board knowledge or approval, supports this concern.

SacRT develops extensive documents, with approval by legal counsel, for a huge number of board decisions. Most of these end up on consent agenda, but some are the subject of public hearings. The current topics on strollers, carts, and bicycles are far more important than most of what is addressed by the board.

No policies on strollers, carts, and bicycles should be implemented without approval by the board.

The policies must include:

  1. Clear language about what the policy is.
  2. Clear language about what the potential penalties for violation are.
  3. Clear information about what will be communicated to riders about the policy. This would include signs posted on light rail and buses, verbal announcements at light rail stations and on buses, and public outreach efforts designed to reach all riders.
  4. Clear information about what Transit Ambassadors and other SacRT staff will communicate to riders about the policy, and appropriate responses to perceived or actual violations.
  5. Documentation of actual safety or customer issues that justify the policy.
  6. Documented review by the SacRT Mobility Advisory Council.

Let me be blunt. I do not trust SacRT staff to develop and implement policy on strollers, carts, and bicycles without board approval. Agenda item 4.1 is ‘for information only’, and nothing indicates that board approval will be sought for these suggestions.

Though these policies have been on the SacRT Mobility Advisory Council meeting agendas for several months, it was deferred all but one of those months, and the discussion on the remaining month was very brief. Again, this is on the board agenda when it has not previously been on the MAC agenda in any meaningful way. The next MAC meeting is November 19.

incremental transit

I wrote a blog post for Sacramento Transit Advocates and Riders (STAR), How to build successful transit, in August 2025, a year ago. It is probably one of the most valuable and insightful posts STAR made, as important today as it was then.

I attended the last SacRT Board meeting on July 27. On the agenda was authorization for SacRT staff to negotiate a grant from the state for a study of bus rapid transit (BRT) to the Sacramento airport (agenda item 2.11 on consent calendar “Authorizing the General Manager/CEO to Execute Agreements with the California Department of Transportation for the Sustainable Transportation Planning Grant Award for the Green Line Bus Rapid Transit to Sacramento International Airport”. The item was not pulled from consent, but three board members commented and said that they were supportive of the study, but still absolutely committed to light rail to the airport. I suspect the other board members felt the same way, but did not comment. The board and many SacRT staff continue to promote light rail to the airport, though they have finally admitted that there is no likelihood of it happening in the near future due to two major issues: lack of agreement with the city and county for crossing the American River, and funding for a bridge at Truxel Road, and the overall cost of the project. The last time it was estimated, it was $2 billion dollars, a cost that will continue to rise and accelerate over the years. The entire capital budget for SacRT, which includes light rail modernization and bus replacement, and fare technology, as well as a large number of other activities, is only $2 billion per year. That portion of the budget includes mostly funding from federal and state sources and grants; it is mostly not Sacramento County Measure A or other local sources. That means, as a practical matter, that the Green Line would zero out an entire year’s budget for everything else, or if spread out over 10 years, 10% of the budget, every year. And the estimate of cost is very conservative.

The public has said, throughout the Transit Idea Exchange process (A Community Collaboration to Shape the Future of Transit), that they did not want huge investments in infrastructure, but instead wanted better and more frequent bus service. How to build better and more frequent bus service? Well, by incrementally improving transit. Back to the STAR model:

I’ve decided to call this incremental transit. As the STAR post noted, the concept did not originate with STAR, but comes from Strong Towns, The Strong Towns Approach to Public Investment, and the ideas presented by Jarrett Walker in Human Transit (the book and the website).

The SacRT Board and many of the SacRT staff want to jump from step 1, or actually, step 0.5, since the frequency of bus service to the airport is hourly, not 30 minutes, to step 5, bypassing all steps in between. That is a mistake. Not only does the approach put any solution off for years, it risks turning the public off to any service to the airport since nothing so far has been successful (the bus is mostly empty). Light rail might be mostly empty as well.